The future of books and reading
Response to module 2- technology and learning
In a continuation to my last blog post I will explore whether printed books will retain a place in the future or instead will they be replaced by digitalised versions? Gibson (2011) discusses the risk of books being neglected for the digital world in her thesis ‘The Impact of Physical Features on the book Selection process of fourth and eighth graders’. In chapter one, Gibson (2011) discusses how children opt for the digital world over books as it is seen as being more engaging and innovative. Gibson claims that “for some, books can’t even begin to compete with the latest technologies available to children, such as the Kindle” (Gibson, 2011, p.1).
In a continuation to my last blog post I will explore whether printed books will retain a place in the future or instead will they be replaced by digitalised versions? Gibson (2011) discusses the risk of books being neglected for the digital world in her thesis ‘The Impact of Physical Features on the book Selection process of fourth and eighth graders’. In chapter one, Gibson (2011) discusses how children opt for the digital world over books as it is seen as being more engaging and innovative. Gibson claims that “for some, books can’t even begin to compete with the latest technologies available to children, such as the Kindle” (Gibson, 2011, p.1).
This makes you wonder will books printed with ink on paper
become a thing of the past, being replaced by the eBook?
Sasson (n.d.) explains that “an eBook is a book in
electronic format”. It is purchased and downloaded off the internet and can be
stored on a computer, laptop, smartphone, iPad, Kindle and any kind of device
that allows text to be read on a screen. There are many benefits to these digitalised
versions of books which critically challenge the purpose and existence of
printed books. One clear positive is the difference in price- digital versions
of books, being much more affordable than their printed counterparts and
sometimes they may even be free (Wood, 2017 & Sasson, n.d.)! As Presnell
(2014) states in her article “nobody has $30 to pay for a book they’ll read
once and then put on a shelf or give away”. Presnell (2014) also raises the
environmental benefits of digital versions as they do not require trees to be
cut down and manufactured into paper for their pages. They are also easy to
access and can be purchased and downloaded within minutes on your device-
eliminating the need to go to the library, bookstore, or to wait for your book
to arrive in the mail (Sasson, n.d.). In addition Karsenti (n.d.) explores the
portability benefits of the eBooks, as hundreds of books can be carried with
you without the concern of weight.
While there are many benefits of the eBook in comparison to
the paper book version Karsenti (n.d.), Gibson (2011) & Wood (2017) all stress
that this comparison overlooks the main issue prevalent in society today. In
their articles (Karsent, n.d., Gibson, 2011 & Wood, 2017) every author
agrees that the real issue is not whether digitalised or printed books are
better but on societies value of reading- claiming that people are just not
interested or motivated to read anymore. So no matter what the version of text,
the underlying issue that needs to be addressed is how to keep the audience
motivated and interested to read.
References:
References:
Gibson, B.L. (2011). The Impact of Physical Features on the book selection
process of fourth and eighth graders (Master’s Thesis, College of Bowling Green
State University, Ohio, United States). Retrieved from https://etd.ohiolink.edu/rws_etd/document/get/bgsu1300468939/inline
Karsenti, T. (n.d.). 25 Main benfits of the eBook. Retrieved from
http://www.karsenti.ca/25_ebook.pdf
Presnell, B. (2014, April 3). Books are meant to be
shared. The Dispatch. Retrieved from http://www.the-dispatch.com/lifestyle/20140403/books-are-meant-to-be-shared
Sasson, R. (n.d.). The Benefits and Advantages of Ebooks. Success
Consciousness. Retrieved from https://www.successconsciousness.com/ebooks_benefits.htm
Wood, Z. (2017, March 18).
Paperback fighter: sales of physical books now outperform digital titles. The guardian. Retrieved from
https://www.theguardian.com/books/2017/mar/17/paperback-books-sales-outperform-digital-titles-amazon-ebooks
I think there are many advantages to e-books but I do wonder whether our brains have adapted to the new technology as much as they need to. Some studies seem to show that there are both mental (comprehension) and physical side-effects from e-books. An example would be Hanho (2012) who looked at a cohort of Korean students. It was found that although students were satisfied with e-books, their comprehension was not as good and physical side effects such as eye-fatigue were worse.
ReplyDeleteHanho, J. (2012). A comparison of the influence of electronic books and paper books on reading comprehension, eye fatigue, and perception. The Electronic Library, 30(3), 390-408. doi:10.1108/02640471211241663